Saturday, March 10, 2018

The Question of Tessen Kata


Tessen

 
There are a great many video of individuals doing Tessen kata, and impressive looking forms at that, The thing is I doubt the Tessen was an Okinawan weapon, rather a Japanese weapon.

First let us look at one of those forms,

A version of the Shuri Ryu form Go Pei Sho using the fan.



 

Certainly looks impressive. Nor would I imply this is easy to do with skill.

I believe however the fan being used is more a heavy weight Chinese version of a fan.

 

And in the Chinese systems there are a variety of different weighted versions. Those for modern WuShu competition are extremely light to allow faster technique to be pleasing for the eye.

 

A more tradition Chinese use of the fan might look like this form.

Shaolin Steel Fan Demo

 

 

Notice the fan is used more with the motion of his form for effectiveness, where the Okinawan fan form he stops and flips the fans open and closed often, more for visual effect than serious fan use, IMO.

 

From my understanding on the Japanese battle field it was carried by the more senior combatants, who were probably running the battles. There was likely more than one type, but those used were to be used against swords trying to slice their heads off, They were much more durable, some even solid fans used as iron shields in fan shape, IMO

 

Of course is is also interesting that I cannot locate anyone from traditional styles using the Tessen either. In that I stand open to being corrected.




 

In all likelihood looking more like the above.

 

Over time change happens, but the reason change occurs is important to understand. Change just for dexterity exercise or for exciting completion is not bad, just different. But change does not equate to the original was something was used.

 

The more time moves forward the more things change.

Friday, March 9, 2018

Happiness is a warm stick, Mama


 
Happiness is a warm stick, Mama
Happiness is a warm stick, Mama
Happiness is a warm stick, Mama
Happiness is a warm stick, Mama
Happiness is a warm stick, Mama

Happiness is a warm stick, Mama

Happiness is a warm gun – the Beatles White Album



 
I have been working stick technique since I began my study
Of the Bando form the Hidden Stick in 1983.
 
Most of the time I used a stick of rattan about 2 feet long.
I also found it works with anything in my hands
Including my empty hands.
 
Now disabled, I still care about
retaining as much martial effectiveness as possible.
So I work with sticks of varying lengths.
 
When I moved I kept one of my sticks,
A gift from one of my former students.
Cynthia Robinson,
Her then current Seattle instructor , gifted to me.
 
It was a rattan escrima stick and always had a nice feel to it.
My other sticks I gifted to my former students.
 
Now though I work frequently with very short hand held sticks,
Increasing my effectiveness with every kata I still do.
 
Another stick, about 10” was cut from a rattan staff
I once used to make a short stick for Reese Rigby, about 1986.
I also made this one for myself.
Reese often did his Bando Hidden Stick form with such a short stick.
I did not use it often,
 
But now I increasingly find it my favorite current stick.
 
Then again I never met a stick I didn’t like.

Monday, March 5, 2018

The Kiai


 


Something that is almost never mentioned in any depth is the Kiai.

 

When I began we were shown to Kiai at seeral points in kata. Most kata 2 kaia. And for Kusanku kata 3 of them. Outside of being shown where to kiai I can remember no discussion of them, Nor was there any discussion of what shout to use.

 

I had a long history of choir singing, in church and school, so making a loud noise was not difficult for me, and somewhere I began using extremely loug kiai when competing with kata.

 

It was not a constant thing, Often in the dojo working on kata I  would not Kiai at all.

 

Then, later, I read a bit about Kiai as a ‘Spirit Shout’, the definition mainly given, and that it could be vocalized ot performed soundless, at any time in a kata. I also understood that the shout was referred to as a Kiai, but the sound produced was not the word Kiai, rather something else.

 

I began to understand the use of Kiai, not a fixed point or sound, rather a focused intensity to use, at times reinforced by sound. But that focused intensity could be done at any instant, for my understanding.

 

Far too soon, right after black belt, I was teaching, and of course taught the youth I was teaching the same Kiai points I was shown, I explained what a Kiai was, demonstrating it, and that the shout was referred to as a Kian, but the shout used was something different. I used a variety of Kiai that I had developed.

 

What I discovered was that beginners would never understand what they were told, and when I told them to Kiai, they would always shout “Kiai” at that point. I also discovered that for beginners, those under Dan, other uses were often beyond their understanding.

 

So Kiai just remained a fixed point in Kata for them, an introduction to be explored later.

 

In those years at the Boys Club of Scranton, at the start of the school year, we would often perform a demonstration of the students’ karate at the Boys Club for parents and family friends.

 

So one year we began with the kids performing a group Seisan Kata, and using their Kiai. Where they literally would shout Kiai at the appropriate points in the kata. And their shouting Kiai was with very small child voices.

Then the parents would give a small titter of laughter when the kids did this.

 

I could not let the chance be missed.

 

In a quiet steady voice (by intention) I asked all the parents to stand up. Then I explained what the Kiai was, not the shout of Kiai that the kids did, rather a very different sound was the future intention. A shout that could strengthen their technique and also stun the opponent setting them up for a defensive response. All the time I was speaking softly.

 

Then I continued speaking, “What the Kiai should sound like is something like this.

 

And then I blasted a Kiai, with all the force I could muster behind it.

 

The parents all dropped to their seats,

 

No more titters, just shocked looks on their faces, and a valuable teaching moment for the kids. The beginning of a lesson….

 

Years later we were no longer doing demonstrations, I had come around to the point that every class possible was too important to miss. And the parents were always welcome to watch class too.

 

No matter how I taught them, new kids (all of them under black belt) would most often still shout a weak kiai when doing group kata. Suddenly, inexpertly I would then respond with a forceful Kata, louder than the entire group together, and the kids would get the same startled look on their face.

 

I continued to make a point.

 

But I did not go further with the kids about Kiai.

 

I had come to realize that Kyu training was more to develop the power in technique and stance, that would then be utilized in Dan training.

 

Developing a Dan was very important to me. It was helping them recognize how much there was still to learn, and that they would be responsible as adults, to chose to train of not train. To learn or to not learn, how much their choice. For that is what we should be training everyone to be able to do, To make responsible decisions every time.

 

For example almost 100% or the youth who reached black belt, will make the responsible decision to leave karate, as their lives are more important to them. School, work, military service, marriage, and so forth are far more important choices for young adults to consider. A very few will make choices that lead to their return. Those who are already in adult lives, can decide to undergo into the depths of Dan instruction, as they have already found a place for karate training in their lives. However in time they will all come to a point where they face other considerations, and if you have done your job right, you will celebrate their choice, even if is to move away from other training.

 

This making choices is another step in understanding how to use Kiai.

 

As I write this audible Kiai is almost an impossibility for me anymore. The weakness in my facial muscle makes most of my speech impossible to understand. But I can still utilize Kiai n what kata I practice.

 

As I have come to understand it kiai is the full use of the body, more correctly a force enhancer with the use of correct body enhancement, another force enhancer too.

 

The vocal version of Kiai, can do more than become a force enhancer. It can serve to startle someone unexpectedly, perhaps just for an instant, but that instant allowing an opening to be created in their defense. There are legends that Kiai alone might kill. Of course who can point to anyone who has really killed with their Kiai. Most likely just the stuff of legends.

 

But at close range, of if attacked in an enclosed space where the sound would be magnified, remember those parents who dropped into their seats and consider what something unexpected might do.


 

More likely the other use of kiai, whether vocal or silent, as another force enhancer, strengthening the force from correct alignment should be considered.

 

To develop such ability is a personal journey, working to make the use of a Kiai when technique is executed with same.

 

An instructor can but point the way. The journey is a solitary path you choose to undertake.

 

A bit unconventional that all things are not used by everyone in all karate practices. But a point of view I developed over my decades working with skilled adepts, each choosing different ways to grow their art.

 

Along my way I was shown a method of incorporating some Aikido in our karate practice, A method where Aikido was integrated into karate training, both arts being present.

 

That does not make me an Aikido-ka by any means, but understanding Aikido a bit because I have done this.

 

I was shown for example the Aikido that could be found in Heian Yon da,

And on my own found many aikido in Chinto kata.

 

I also discovered I never met an Aikido book I did not like. At the same time even a good book would sit on my shelves for many years before I would realize what it contained.

 

Back around 2000 I purchased “Total Aikido the Master Course” by Shioda Gozo. I realized it was a good read, but it took me 18 years before I realized how much karate was in there, and great links by me between understanding karate principles from an aikido point of view.

 

One such moment is where Shioda describes ‘Atemi Striking’ and I see a relevance to Kiai too. The word Atemi meaning the strike, what we use constantly in karate.

 

“The moment of contact becomes the strike.

 

The founder, Usheiba Sensei, said, “In a real battle, atemi is seventy percent, technique is thirty percent.” The training that we do in the dojo is designed to teach us various sots of techniques, the correct way to move our body, effective way of using our power, and how to create a relationship with the other person.

 

In a real battle, we must use the power that we have developed in our bodies in the dojo and use it explosively in an instant; we must decide the outcome of the fight at that moment. In that situation atemi becomes very important.

 

In aikido, we don’t use any special strength to apply atemi, Just like in all the other techniques, we can generate power through  the use of focused energy. For example, in the case of shomen-tsuki, if you can use the front knee to effectively transfer off os the power of the forward movement of your body, all of the body’s energy will be transferred to your fist. Basically, this is the same as the principle of hiriki no yosei (elbow power movement.

 

In atemi timing if of course very important. When uke comes toward you, if you can time it so that you make your strike at the moment he is off-balance you will be able to hit with great power. Strikes as they are used in aikido are not limited to just hitting with the fist of tegatana (side of the hand). If you make contact with the uke with focused power, that is atemi, si it is possible to use your shoulder, your back, or any part of your body to make the atemi.

 

There is a lot to think about there,

 

The relationship with Atemi and our striking is but one possibility.

 

But the way they talk about focused power behind the striking, does suggest parallels to karate Kiai too. Now an Aikdo-ka mignt not agree with me, suggesting they are very different things. I just suggest there are similarities too. And how often do you think about striking an attacker with your back reinforced with kiai…. Hmmm.

 

To think… perchance to dream…. And

Sunday, March 4, 2018

Our Kicking


The other night I started thinking on the layers behind training. Where you find there is more flex behind things than basic training.


 

Then I looked on the wall of the club and saw my original kicking drills chart, which I learned my first night.

 

Not Kicking (Keri) in Salisbury was layered, there were these basics, but you were encouraged to go to whatever level of other kicking you could handle.

 

Much the same way, these basics are the basis of keri in Isshinryu, but we have Young Lee doing a bang up job taking kicking far beyond that.  But that does not mean these kicks are less, either.

 

So I started thinking of them a new way.

 

So starting with the Original Lower Body Combinations of Lewis Sensei


 

 

First probably the original Okinawan kick was the front kick, So I reordered the kicks to front kick and front kick similarities first.

 


 


Original Lower Body Combinations of Lewis Sensei


 

The original kick was likely the front kick

1.    Front Snap Kick Seisan, Chinto,

a.     Ball of the foot

b.    Goju version ball of the foot into a descending heel kick

c.     The variety of toe kicks

d.    With the heel which the Okinawans used for sparring from Lewis Sensei

2.    Front Kick (Side) – version from Wansu ending (old version contained a knee strike

a.     Wansu, Kusanku

3.    Heel Strike (Knee) – to the Sunsu version

4.    Knee Strike – Wansu version and the Sunsu version Wansu

a.     Rising Knee Strike,

b.    Inward Knee Strike – taught by Charles Murray

5.    Cross Kick-

                                                             i.       originally a stomp to someone on the floor for finishing.

                                                          ii.      Then to someone’s legs

6.    Squat Kick a front kick delivered on a 45 angle Sunsu

 

7.    Front Thrust (from floor)

 

These blade of the foot kicks are probably done because of Miyagi Chogun and the influence of Goju Ryu

 

8.      Knee Strike (45degrees)  Sunsu

9.       Side Snap Kick Wansu, Sunsu

10.   Side Kick (45 degrees rear)

Other sources

11.    Side Kick (on  Floor)

12.     Back Side Kick and then a (Rear 45 degrees), Rear Kick

 

Other kicks

 

13.        Crescent kick - Kusanku

14.        Rear Kick

15.        Double Jump Kick

a.     Jumping Kick - Chinto

b.    Double Jumping kick Kusanku

16.          Roundhouse Kick

 

17.        Stepping forward and backward

18.         Naifanchi Side Stepping

a.     Use of such stepping into the lower legs of the opponent

 
I have always maintained that Isshinryu contains most of the variety of kicking found on Okinawa. Of course there are layers to this, and I have included a few of them, such as the front kick from Goju Seisan. I dealt with this kick in my blog post Quicker than the eye can see

 


All of which makes me think further. I am reminded how Tris Sutrisno would take the kata he taught and turn them into short drills, working the technique series of the kata. Now as interesting as that was I didn’t do the same with our art. But I am wondering is the kicks could be taught in a different order, such as tied to the kata being learnt.

 

Still students would learn the entire se, but the kicking would be directly tied to the kata. And kicks not in the kata as additional drills for everyone. I have no direct suggestions at this time, just a consideration.

My .pdf showing some of the depth behind goju kicking is interesting.

Or consider the .pdf of the kicking technique of Sesan Toun’Ryu

 

I have also recently created two pdf.s on kicks in SunNuSu (Sunsu).

Or the .pdf showing Andy Sloan doing the first ½ of Sunsu kata.

 

Another recent thought on the same thing, which also ties into the layers of learning.

 

First these varieties come from a variety of systems. There is nothing to suggest one should do everything, However knowing what others may use is often helpful.

 

1. To begin the standard in most systems the front kick with the ball of the foot.

2. a variation we use in Isshinryu where the front foot comes off of the floor at a 45 degree angle to strike with the ball of the foot.

3. a variation we in many Isshinryu schools where the front foot comes off of the floor at a 45 degree angle to strike with the instep.

4. The front kick with the instep.

6. Variations of the front kick where the kick moves past the target and uses the returning heel for striking from being.

7. The entire range of front kicks where the toes are used for the strike; there are many varieties of this kick. One example is found in the kicking developed for Uechi Ryu.

8. The front kick with a ‘stomp’ and the sole of the foot strikes into the knee.

9. The front kick with the ball of the foot, which then changes into a heel strike downward, as if striking the hip joint and then driving the kick down as if to break that joint.

10. The front kick with the instep.

11. The front stomp kick as in driving down the heel into the knee of someone.

12. The front stomp kick as in driving down the heel into a foot.

13. The front stomp kick driving the heel down into the groin, and then the toes ripping downward.

14. Even the way the Tou’on Ryu uses their front front kick is a very different variation from what others do.

I am quite sure that I haven’t considered all the possible versions. Nor the different methods of execution.

 

Then you might consider a variety of drills we use.

 

Itosu 8 point kicking reconstructed be me from a description in John Sells ‘Unante’

 

 

Mabuni 7 point kicking reconstructed by me from a description of the drill from Joe Swift.

 

 

The Kihon Ni Dan drill we use

 

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Testing or Not

 
When my original instructor trained under Shimabuku Tatsuo there was not testing done by anyone. Shimabuku Sensei simply awarded new rank whenever he felt someone was ready for new challenges. The same held true for black belt, one night it was just handed to the individual.

 
In turn when my instructor, Tom Lewis and then Charles Murray taught they kept to the same paradigm about rank, kyu ranks were never tested just awarded as the instructor felt was appropriate. Rank was not given for attainment, rank was another challenge for the recipient.

 
Somewhere he made a change and the Sho Dan examination was added. The individual could fail it, but it was more than a test in my eyes, more akin to an initiation. After that rank promotions reverted to the Shimabuku standard, no some evening the individual just was awarded the rank, and gained new challenges to conquest.

 
I kept pretty much to the same standard, it did require me to follow each students progress, up, down and sideways at times. Then recognizing that individual was ready for new challenges, which I put before them. Over and over and over, No one ever was at an end. There were always decades of work ahead.

 
What an individual attained, was after all their choice.

 
Some just continued to train.
Some continued to train and move into deeper waters.
A very few chose to become instructors, a very different path.

 
Each becoming what their karate would be.

 
Step by step, day by day, week by week, month by month,
Year by year, Decade by decade I kept sharing more material.
And of course determining when they were ready for new challenges.

 
Which in turn meant I had to continue learning more and more about my art.