Thursday, May 26, 2022

Change in martial arts discussion over the years.

 


Times have changed incredibly fast over the years.

 

I can remember when there were very, very few books on the martial arts. At that time the karate magazines and their letters pages were more like the internet.

 

At that time karate was what your instructor told you karate was. Then I began to additionally train with very, very skilled others and a different vision emerged.

 

Then video tape became available, and selling karate video tapes began. I remember when Goju folks talked mysteriously about Superimpe but never showed it. Then a video version was sold by Panther and I got one, which led to a small disillusionment for me. It was not what my imagination assumed it might me. Not it wasn’t a fine form, but I had imagined something else (I guess after learning a ton of Northern Chinese foms I though it would be something different than it was.)

 

Then PCs and email, where you actually wrote to each other, just like letters.

 

Then the internet, and YahooGroups, I began on the getting between Pat McCarthy and Jim Keenan of the original Isshinryu list, they were shouting about a translation/mistranslation on the Bubishi (then new) McCarthy the author, Jim a Translator Isshinryuy/Tai Chi/Baqua/Krav Maga stylist, I got involved shouting it was wrong for seniors to behave so in public. Of course I had no idea what discussion on the internet was like.

 

Later I joined the Cyberdojo on YahooGroups, Again in 2000 Patrick McCarthy was having a heated discussion with George Donahue, and George handed him his head as he didn’t realize George was raised in Japan/Okinawa, and was trained by the Kashiba brothers among others.

 

I just found that lengthy discussion (I kept the hard copy) and so different the discussion in degree from what Facebook is today.

 

Things kept changing from YahooGroup discussions, to dvd’s, to and to Facebook. Some things are better, There is far less discussion in depth, more discussion light. Less chance where people have a chance to grow what they understand.

 

With all the bells and whistles today, it is also extremely less.


 


Saturday, May 21, 2022

The Ramen Girl

 


There are times when you look in a different direction you see something else. I was just watching the movie “The Ramen Girl” on TUBI. While I have seen it before, and enjoyed it, it has a lot going for it that just an unusual ROM.

 

It is about as American girl in Japan who decided to learn how to make ramen. And she does not know Japanese but  takes the local ramen shop owner to be her Sensei.

 

What follows as she enters and slowly move forward in her quest, to me also likely gives a glimpse at what those art that became known as karate were like. There have been more than a few tales about what the student-Sensei relationship was like. This movie has many similarities. Of course it isn’t about karate, rather it is about noodles.

 

The interesting thing is the Ramen Grand Master tastes her creation, and calls it good, but she needs more time and less originality.

 

But her teacher/Sensei declares her his successor and finally she opens a Ramen restaurant in Paris.

 

In a way there was not a grandmaster of the past who passed on an instructor’s student, and it was the instructor who likely declared an individual as his successor.

 

One can find meaning in the most unusual places.


 


Wednesday, May 18, 2022

A visit by Ed Summer

Today was a very special day.

Ed Summer a Goju instructor from Buckeye Arizona, spent some time to visit me.

We had a great time exchanging war stories, and many other details about our training.





Thank you so much for the visit Ed.

Tuesday, May 17, 2022

Okinawan Karate at 100 after being introduced to Japan

 

Translated with Bing Translate

https://efight.jp/news-20220517_1057600...

 

KarateSpread from Okinawa to the mainland, karate wear was also born on this day, today is exactly 100 years = May 17

 


  May 17,  2022 marks exactly 100 years since karate was introduced from Okinawa to the Japanese mainland.

 

 One hundred years ago, on May 17, 1922, the day that Yoshinori Funakoshi, the founder of Shotokan Karate, performed karate (then known as Karate) to the public for the first time at the Kodokan Dojo of Judo.

 

 This day was during the 1st Sports and Sports Exhibition organized by the Ministry of Education (April 30 ~ May 31, 1922: Tokyo Women's Higher Normal School Attached Museum of Education), where Funakoshi went to Tokyo and performed karate at the Kodokan.

 

VideoThere was a blow of karate in judo! The physical art of judo born from this exchange

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmsEz_QPG5s&t=82s

Video No Longer Avainable

Shinya Aihara, the editor-in-chief of Shin Karatedo and a karate collector, is one of those who looked up the day from old books. "It was a presentation of shapes, promissory hands, and a question-and-answer session. On this day, about 250 people, including Kodokan disciples, students, officials, military personnel, police officers, and newspaper and magazine reporters, gathered to see the first public presentation of karate. It is a day when karate became known and spread throughout the world. By the way, there was no such thing as a dojo suit in karate at the time of going to Tokyo, so it was plain clothes. For that reason, it is said that Funakoshi saw the judo suit and referred to it, hurriedly bought a cloth and made it all night," says the anniversary of the first karate suit being made.

 

Jigoro Kano tried to incorporate this karate into the shinobi department of judo in earnest, and although it did not actually disappear, the form of judo's "energetic goodness" can be seen by incorporating some of the techniques of hitting from this exchange of karate.

 

Toshinori Omori, who wrote "What is Oshinin?", says, "This was the beginning of everything, and without it, Olympic karate, Kyokushin, kick and K-1 would not have been born." How about looking back on what karate is on this memorable day?

Monday, May 16, 2022

The day a group from Fighting Arts.com came to visit me at my fathers

 

Re: Coming To America [Re: Ed_Morris]
     
#15845182 - 04/16/06 10:28 AM

 




Wow! What a great day we had yesterday! First I had my last TKD lesson at Scott's school. I enjoyed it but was a bit sad to be saying goodbye after training there almost every day since I got here.

After lunch we drove to Matt and Tami's where we met Garrett (Ranger G). Ranger is a cool guy, it was great to meet him. We all drove to visit Victor Smith who was visiting with his father. The weather was great so we all sat outside and exchanged a brief summary of our MA history before Victor demonstrated a small portion of his knowledge. He demonstrated some bunkai to the Isshin Ryu Seisan and Chinto, showed us how he uses single knuckle strikes and how to improve our balance through proper alignment by making a few (seemingly) minor adjustments.

Victor also performed some Tai Chi for us and demonstrated how it can be used as self defence


After we left Victor, Matt, Tami, Garret, Scott and I went to a restaurant where I tasted a local delicacy called Blooming Onion and then had steak.













(Lto R Razorfoot, still wadowoman, MattJwife, MattJ, RangerG)


----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Not sure if I was fat enough yet, after we said goodbye to Garret, Matt and Tami took me to Dairy Queen. Oh my goodness - ice cream heaven!

Then it was back to their house where we talked for ages, watched old videos of Matt and Scott beating each other up and also we practiced some sticky hands. Matt and Scott are quite good at this but I think it's incredibly difficult.


I stuffed a few more of Tami's delicous cookies before we said goodbye (only to be polite, you understand )

I really was sorry to say goodbye to Matt and Tami, they are wonderful people and great hosts. I feel like I have known them for years.

Shanon

--------------------
The heart does not know space or time. Limited physical time together is really meaningless.

From the looks of the photo in the restauraunt...The bloomin' onion didn't stand a chance. Poor Also the photos answered a question that I've pondered since I was a kid... "What does Santa do for the other 364 days of the year?". Apparently he delivers nerve strikes and cavity presses to all the little boys who were on the naughty list. It seems being a nice guy has once again turned around to bite me on the a$$.

Oldman

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Oldman..it was TWO Blooming Onions..and no, they did not stand a chance...


I can say with honesty, I walked away yesterday with more skills than some seminars I have paid good money for. Mr. Smith is the Grand Master of understatement... I was blown away by his skills and teaching methods. I intend to keep the little gems of information and technique I learned yesterday to myself.

Sharon was the vision of an Angel, albet an inked (swoon) and very dangerous Angel... It was a signal honor to meet this very skilled and personable lady. I cannot wait for her to jump the puddle again to work weapons disarms and learn some of her style. When she found out I owned a real Scottish Great Kilt and could speak with a Scottish Burr...ah..but that is a story for another day...

I had been waiting for over a year to meet Razorfoot, and whilst a friend of MattJ's (I overlooked that), he is one intimidating guy. Nice as heck...but those shoulders and arms send a clear warning... I think "WMD" would be a more appropriate screen name.

All in all, a great day and evening. I regret I could not stay for Dairy Queen as I had a two hour ride back home on the Harley.

Like all fightingarts get togethers, this has been both a social pleasure, and an educational experience.

 Ranger G

- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Victor is a wealth of MA knowledge. He showed us some very subtle stuff that really made quite a difference in application. Proper body alignment is key. Amazing what a big difference some small adjustments can make.

Victor also showed us some painful nerve strikes, and a vicious Tai Chi body shot that almost put RazorFoot on the ground. He showed some interesting uses for chambers in Kata that were very reminiscent of what I know as "reverse motion" in AKK, which I have never seen used in any other art.

Victor is not a nice guy , however, and taunted us cruelly with a lack of explanation to his mysterious body alignment techniques. He dared us to "talk about it.....you won't be able to figure it out." Despite discussing it on the way to the restaurant and afterwards, he was right. CURSE YOU VICTORRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!!!!!!!

MattJ

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

MattJ,

It was a real pleasure to meet you (and your wife), Razor, Wadowoman and Ranger G on Saturday. I'm sorry we didn't have more time, perhaps it will work out better on a future visit down to Red Lion.

Earlier in the day I had actually taught the Goju kata Saifa to Don Gladfelter's Shotokan East in York, Pa., and it made for a very busy Saturday.

You may feel free to curse me as much as you need to, <GRIN>, about the body alignment, unfortunately it's not a quick study, and long term development (as I practice it) really concides with kata practice and study.

I realize I was sort of shotgunning a few martial concepts and not presenting much in a coherent manner, but first meetings bridge the gap what we have in common. Most of my work is directly tied into the Isshinryu and Yang Tai Chi Chaun studies I practice, and to extract them for others training isn't something I've focused on a great deal.

But if I've given you something to think about, that's ok too (Been there and done that more than a few times myself).

And for anyone making cracks about me looking like Santy, well I might have a prize up my bag for you <GRIN>

--------------------
Victor Smith





George Scott (Razorfoot)

Sharon Hawker-Badderley  (StillWadowoman)

Matt Janson (MattJ)

Garrett Derr Sr.  (Ranger G)


 


Quote:



"What does Santa do for the other 364 days of the year?". Appearantly he delivers nerve strikes and cavity presses to all the little boys who were on the naughty list.




Yes.He.Does....and it appears I was on the naughty list too..a well earned member of the naughty list I might add..

The nerve strikes to the arm tickled a a bit...

--------------------
"If you're gonna be stupid, you better be tough."

Ranger G


 

Sunday, May 15, 2022

ISSHIN- Concentration the Art (explaination)


 

 Just be perfectly clear, I do not consider myself a great expert.

Likely many who look at my blog posts know a great deal more than I do, and have greater experiences.

 

I created my blog to share with my 5 senior students our shared training so they could remember what we did over 30 years together. And to share some of what I attempted to study and/or read. I do not believe information should be hidden (abet there is a great deal I have shared with them privately).

 

I have never looked for remote students and am not through this sharing.

 

It is simply my best recollection of what I have seen or experienced. And some of it may be incorrect. Most of this I never had time to share with my students over our decades together. Their own training was always more important. But I want them to have access o what I have seen, in case it proves useful for the future needs.

 

I expect some will read and discard. A smaller amount will attempt to learn it for themselves. Of course is is not possible to do so, as I would have shared it, But if from their own efforts they can make any of it their own by their own efforts, they deserve it and I applaud their efforts.

 

I guess I have shared several books of material on my blog. That came about as part of my jobs required me to be literate and that in turn made me take better notes of what I have experienced.

 


A friend, Jim Keenan, feels that what I have done is unique, for he is unaware of anyone who has freely done so. As a surprise he gathered some of my posts and created a book of them for me. It was done as a gift, not for profit. He just wanted to see these notes in book form.

 

I hope my memories may give some to think further about the arts we love, me haps to add a word or to so that I may gain greater knowledge and/or correct an error at times.

 

I have great fun writing of my experiences and sharing them.

 

Thank you for listening to me.

 

 

 

The book I referenced:

 

https://isshin-concentration.blogspot.com/2020/02/isshin-writings-on-martial-arts-and.html

Friday, May 13, 2022

A personal observation of training with others.

  


When as a green belt I had to leave Salisbury for Scranton, I quickly discovered there was no karate of any sort being taught in town.

 The largest system there was teaching Tang Soo Do Moo Duk Kwan under Frank Trajanowicz.

 

They had a small satellite School in Clarks Summit North of Scranton, and when I visited it I met the Chief Instructor and he described  the system. I signed a two year contract and received a payment book for the monthly charge.

 

When I showed for the first class, the school classes were being run by a red belt (brown belt) and as I was warming up in the back room running some Isshinryu forms, he came back and informed me that I would not be allowed to do them in the school. Then in my first class I learned two of their forms.

 

The training worked up a hard sweat, I spent a lot of time kicking. And within several months I had learned 5 forms.

 

Then one day I was informed that there would be quarterly testing as the main Scranton school the following Saturday. (they had quarterly rank testing) and paid my fee for the test.

 

When I climbed up 4 floors to the school, I entered and found out I knew no one. So I changed and entered the school floor to warm up and began doing the 5 forms I knew.

 

One blue belt (their black belt) came over and addressed me, that as a new white belt I should not do all the forms.

 

Later when called up for my testing group, I was asked to perform the techniques I had studied. Then I had to punch through one board set on cinder caps. Finally I was told to perform the 5th form.

After I was done I went back to sit with the rest of the students.

 

When all the tests were concluded, they announced the promotions. I was promoted from 1st white to 5th green.

 

A little later the Clarks Summit school closed and I moved to the Scranton main school.

 

The point is for the two years I trained there, where I moved from 10th gup white to 1st gup red no one ever asked to see what my Isshinryu looked like.

 

[Sparring was not a regular part of their classes. Those classes were very infrequent. And when they did spar they wore hard chest protectors. They discovered even with those protectors my strikes to their body often dropped my opponent to the floor. But what they wanted were more and more Korean kicking.]

 

A year after I started that program Charles Murray moved to Scranton. I gave him no chance and began training with him I also continued to train in TSDMDK because of my contract.

 

Charles trained me most extensively with continual hard contact kumite between ourselves. He was very hard, I was the target, Charles literally poured the Isshinryu system as he knew it into me. A year after I began training with him my contract ended. I went to Master Trojanowicz and explained why I was leaving.


Charles and I trained and trained, many times at midnight.We attended tournaments together, but because of his responsibilities, he never saw me compete, he always came later to enter black belt kumite.

 

Then before I knew it I was tested by Lewis Sensei and the entire IKA and received my black best. Yet a few months later he returned to become an office in the USAF. I was on my own.

 

Having on one to push me, I started going to 20 tournaments a year to find some push. There I met many other instructors and as a result I began visiting others taking advantage of their offers, the real reason I wanted someone to spar with.

 

I would find that would be a standard as schools where I was invited to train and share in their classes.

 

I began studying Tai Chi Chaun from Ernest Rothrock, eventually studying various Chinese forms from him (wanting to become a more knowledgeable judge of Chinese Stylists. And that association lasted for decades, But never once did he ask to see my Isshinryu forms. I never participated in sparring with his student.

 

As a brown belt I attended an open TSD tournament up the line from Scaraton. Competing there I met other students from a local Kempo Goju school. Those guys invited me to come up and spar with them. That began several years of visiting them. I did not go there to learn Kempo Goju, but to spar. Dave Brojack the head instructor allowed me to work on my Isshinryu kata, and then join in their sparring sessions. Again they really did not comment on my Isshinryu. We became friends, often going to tournaments were each other competed.

 

After a time I met others at tournaments and took advantage of training offerings extended.

 

Steve Newman  of Goshin Jutsu offered and often privately watched my Chinese forms, yet never asked to see my Isshinryu. Likewise I was never asked to spar when I was there.

 

I met Tristan Sutrisno competing against each other is kata and weapons. When invited I traveled to his school, and learned ever so much of his family Shotokan, Aikido, Kobudo and Tjimande. Our association lasted 10 years.  But never did he ask see my Isshinryu forms. And while he was incredible at sparring, always able to go straight through anybody, Never once did I see any sparring in his school during and of the training I experienced. Yet his students did compete in sparring.

 

Then Carl Long, of Shorin Ryu Ezio Shiabuku lineage, invited me to to  train at his school on Saturday mornings (when we were not at tournaments) And we shared many of our practices for several years. But never once did he ask to see my Isshinryu forms. Nor did we ever spar.

 

I trained several days with Ed Savage of Ithica in Goju Ryu. One of my students trained with him while attending college. He went out of his way to instruct me in 5 Goju forms even to giving me photo copies of the forms from his instructors book. But the sharing was one way, never did I get a chance to show my Isshinryu to him. Yep, no sparring, but our time was so short.

 

More time passed I trained with a Washin Ryu school in Wilkes-Barre at times, again never was I asked to demonstrate my isshinryu.  No sparring.

 

I trained with a Goshin Jutsu instructor in Wilkes-Barre a few times, was most welcome there, yet once again I was never asked to demonstrate my Isshinryu. No sparring.

 

There were other local programs where I trained. Goshin Do and Synko Ryu among others, but again on one ever asked to see my Isshinryu. Yep, no sparring.

 

Then moving to Derry I visited and trained with a Tae Kwon Do instcutor and a Goju instructor. But never was I asked to demonstrate my Isshinryu. Nor was I ever invited to spar.

    

Once Tom Chan, one of my black belts, took me to the George Mattson Karate Barn in Mass. George was not there that day. I was allowed to enter the form practice, and they were mildly amused that I could do their Seisan. Tom, a former Uechi Brown Belt, had taught me the form. Of course they did not ask to se my Isshinryu and no sparring that day.

 

One day I met a Shotokan instructor, Don Gladfelter, who lived very near my parents. Again I went to train with him, He wanted to see some of my Sutrisno Shotokan (I later introdusce him to Tristan and he started training under him. He never expressed an interest to see my Isshinryu. Again never experienced sparring in his school. But his son, Boomer, was very experienced at tournaments.

 

Then I spent more time focused on my own program. When others came to inquire about joining the adult program and they had senior rank in their own system. They found out while I encouraged their own study of their system before or after class. My program was only my Isshinryu and everyone, with prior experience of not, all started at the beginning.

 

Now I worked hard to retain everything I experienced. Not that I was perfect, but was learning to take notes after training as to what I experienced. I did that with everyone above.

 

Now except with Ernest Rothrock where I was studying to learn very specific things, for my own reasons. At all the other schools I was not going to train there to learn those systems, but with the hope I would gain someone to spar with. That did not occur.

 

I certainly did not train with everyone, this record is just what I personally experienced.


When you visit and train at a school, they really are interested only in their art. They are never trying to understand what you are about. Part of the reason is that it looks good to let their students see others are coming to them.

 

Realistically they will never want to see your kata or how you train.

And what I discovered is that they do not want you to spar.

 

You can still learn a great deal, whether you learn anything is up to your own efforts.

Thursday, May 12, 2022

Then there were the times I tried to trick Sherman Harrill

 


 

I had trained with Sherman Harrill more that a bit at clinics and well understood the depth of his teachings. But I had also seen more that a few things from the many I had trained with.

 

There came the time I tried to test what Sherman would do.

 

One of my studies with Tristan Sutrisno was in his use of Aikido. Perhaps not standard aikido but aikido more geared towards his Shotokan studies.

 

Eventually I learned a method to counter the wrist wrap lock. Quite simple just the instant the opponent wraps his hands around your hand, the instant before that lock is set, what you do is move your hand slightly to the side. That’s all that is required.

 

That wrist lock is quite painful so at to move you down on your knees, but the secret is that their alignment to yours must remain intact. In effect their sphere of engagement touching your sphere must be perfectly aligned to work. By moving your arm, providing they do not shift also, you move your wrist out of alignment of their dynamic sphere of engagement. Neutralizing that lock.

 

I had taught that to my students, and they were practiced at doing so.

 

Sherman was using the late John Dinger as his target for some technique ending in that wrist lock.

 

John looked at me and I nodded to him.

 

When Sherman began his wrist wrap lock, John moved his wrist  slightly to the outside, which broke Sherman alignment.

 

Sherman stopped then immediately did something else dropping John.

 

Lesson learned.

 

Yet another time during  the 1997 Wansu kata application potential clinic I attempted something else.

 

I took a minute using one of my students to show him an Indonesian Tjimande drill I had been taught (Juru No. 1).

 

Where your opponents strikes out with their left hand to your face, then strike out with their right hand to your face, following up with a left uppercut to your body. 1,2,3.

 

The response to attack 1 is to parry right with your right shuto hand then to attack 2 parry left with your right ridge hand. To conclude attack 3 with a dropping right hand parry with your right descending  nukite. Responding 1,2,3 Each right strike stopping the attack’ The 3rd defense can also be done with both the left and right descending nukite simultaneously striking.

 

So I demonstrated the series, first with the right open hand. Then I demonstrated the series with each strike being stopped by a right leopard paw strike using the ridge of finger knuckles striking in to the biceps of each attack, much more painful. The 3rd defense can also be done with both the left and right descending leopard paws simultaneously striking

 

The third set of responses used the right single knuckle strike into the opponen’ts biceps stopping each attack with even greater pain.  The 3rd defense can also be done with both the left and right descending single knuckle fists simultaneously striking

 

 

Now I knew Sherman had never studied Tjimande and thought he would find it interesting.

 

Of course Sherman being Sherman showed me a 4 th and simple way to perform the defense. One not suggested in the other 3 methods.