kumite was different. When I began
there was no Safety-gear (then probably an idea in Jhoon Rhee’s mind.) And the rules were often different. I remember
my first tournament (in Baltimore at Mr. Condes tournament) where they allowed
groin attacks because of the kung-fu guy’s were concerned the rules were too
restrictive to their art, and the only people who successfully used the groin
to strike were my friends from our groups dojo.
recall another tournament which was old style, no protective gear was allowed
(even mouth pieces and groin protective gear). And they checked each competitor
in each division. The tournament floor was also bare concrete.
just did our karate. No matter what the rules.
for the time, there were few books. No movies in distribution showing the
various styles, No internet, the closest thing were the few monthly magazines.
Nothing like YouTube allowing you to find anything by a quick search. And while
the concept of training with others existed, it was not a question most could
was no concept of ‘Bunkai’ discussed
openly anywhere. The thought of cross training was not discussed as an option
because there was no term like that then.
was a new black belt, my instructor, Charles Murray, returned to the Air Force, as an
officer. My original instructor, Tom Lewis, was very far away, and though I visited
there as often as possible for the most part I was very much on my own. Only
somewhat different from what the original pioneers in our arts experienced,
though of course people did know the arts did exist.
quickly realized both how much my instructor’s had shared, and how little I
knew at the same time. Besides continuing training youth through the Scranton Boys Club, I turned to the
many open tournaments in the Pennsylvania area to push myself. Using the
competition as an ‘instructor’ of sorts.
completion in the Pennslyvania, New Jersey, Maryland area was of great variety.
And many of the competitors were very skilled in a wide range of arts, eclectic
to very traditional. And from the completion floor I began to make many
the fall of 1979 I saw Ernest Rothrock was opening a school in my town.
And among the demonstrations was one for Tai
Chi. I had read about tai chi in college and always found it interesting.
So I attended that demonstration and liked what I saw. I stuck up a
conversation with him and found he would be willing to teach me. I am sure I
was as much fun to work with as a bag of cement, but I kept at it. I was not
interested in Tai Chi for martial purposes , not was he interested in Tai Chi
as a martial study for me. At that time, besides his schools, and his many
studies, he was focusing on Northern
Eagle Claw for his personal training.
for two years I trained with him on the Yang form and Yang sword,
was also visiting those schools that were in my area to train. Not for rank,
not to learn those arts, not to change my Isshinryu because of any lack I saw.
I had much free time after my daily job, so I trained about 6 days a week.
Within the area I could travel there was no Isshinryu. I was completely on my
something Ernest said to me, that ” if I
was a black belt,
‘I could never
say I can’t’”,
and so I worked very hard to remember everything I experienced. Continual
practice, beginning to take notes, realizing each experience might not be
repeated so work to ‘learn’ everything I was shown. And along the way I
9 months into my Tai Chi studies, I started other studies into the Northern
Chinese Arts with Ernest, studying a vast array of forms. I was only interested
in understanding the breadth of the Chinese Arts.
taught them slow. Some took a year to learn. Of course in that process it did
have some impact on my karate, too. What he showed me were not beginning forms
of those systems, but advanced studies for the most part, or beginning studies
where appropriate for me. This was not the course he taught his students. I
came to understand, besides his focus, he managed to stay atop hundreds of
forms. His schools leaving him great time to personally train. In that sense I
hardly touched the surface of his studies.
I found similarities to my own system at times. I did not seek karate’s origins
from those studies. Just a chance to sweat.
training, teaching, studying Tai Chi and studying Chinese forms didn’t occupy
all my time. So I began to train at other schools. Shotokan, Kempo Goju, Washin
Ryu, Goshin Jutsu, Shorin Ryu and Goju Ryu schools among them. Always to be
pushed and sweat. But I was learningnot
to say what I can’t do and working to retain whatever I saw. No I was not
perfect, much I was not able to retain, but I was trying.
began to realize how vast the martial experience was. While Ernest also began
teaching me on another level, by privately asking me leading questions which in
time I realized he simply could have shown me answers. I began to separate the
different experiences I was having.
those days no place I trained did they discuss ‘bunkai’. Certainly not with Ernest, of course now I realize he did
not share application studies because I didn’t have the requisite skill, not
that he didn’t have them. But he certainly laid the ground work for the
possibility of applications.
I made friends with Tristan Sutrisno, only there did I hear the
concept ’Bunkai’. About this time the magazines has discovered the concept and
articles were beginning to discuss this. During classes shared with Sutrisno
Sensei he would question why no one else did this. In time I came to study the ‘bunkai’
for his Shotokan. What I found was ‘bunkai’ of a type unlike anything else I
had heard about. His father studied under Funakoshi in Japan in the 1930’s, and
their approach I came to understand is close to what other students of Itosu
used to explain how to use Karate technique, but the Sutrisno methodology was
course I began to take copious notes.
may consider those years spent were cross-training. I was just training and
doing my best to remember.
it have an impact on my Isshinryu? I suppose it did. But not for my students in
those days. What it did was give me a reason to train at my Isshinryu with
there is much more to my training. Let me make a point. What is seen as cross
training, to me was more the opportunity to continue to push myself. If I had
remained in the area of my original instructor, I would have done none of this.
Nor would that have been to a detriment. It just changed the shape of how I
continued to remain a black belt.
the years I did add small pieces of the studies to my student’s programs. To
give them knowledge, provide different techniques to apply Isshinryu against,
to make them work in different ways, to make them unpredictable. And of course
at times give them reasons to hate me as they move into dimensions of movement
for which their studies have not prepared them.
students have the right to train anywhere they wish. They are adults after all.
But few have the time. Here they might touch, Shorin Ryu, Goju Ryu, Pai Lum and Shotokan. At times even with my
all have the time to choose where we spend our resources. Did this help
motivate me to work on my Isshinryu to even greater depth? Yes, often finding
those techniques learned elsewhere were already part of Isshinryu, seen when
you just change your perspective.
never worried about mastering anything, just to keep working at it. As time
changes what you do, you continually have to retrain who you are.
was mostly a time before I gained greater insight into Isshinryu’s potential
Harrill, but that is another tale.
more you know about your opponent the more informed choices you can make.
that makes sense it rarely works out that way. Serendipity enters and you may
be facing anyone with any level of skill.
as training advances working to understand how other system do things increases
will give one example. Suppose you face a seniorstylist in Fann Tzi Ying Jow Pai (Northern Eagle Claw), and the technique choice you face is a claw
to your left arm, then they retract their claw to place a claw on your throat.
of the equation is knowing the person has senior ability with the Eagle Claw.
finishing claw to the throat which might choke or rip the throat, depending on
how it is applied. While a concern is not the real threat, that would be the
initial claw to the forearm, before they pull that arm after the grab has
reason for this is the manner which the clawing movement is developed over the
years, Both a combination of strength training, and drills that develop the
sensitivity to enter any attack and form that claw.
reason the initial claw is critical is that they are not just grabbing the
limb. The manner in whichthey condition
the hand allows their clawing motion to cause intense pain. That claw immobilizes
you with that pain, and sets up the closing throat claw.
the best defense is not to allow the initial claw in the first place. Or if the
claw is set, have technique well practiced so you can react through that pain
to counter it and allow you to respond to the following claw.
theoretical answer is to begin the Kata
Nihanchi movement for a interior line of defense open hand left side block
against their initial punch which then turns into a claw. As that claw begins
to form then take that arm and punch down as their other arm begins reaching
for your throat. Your right hand strikes up into their reaching arm. This would
deflect their arm upward. Continuing with that uppercut, the arm after the
strike drops the elbow down into their upper chest.
realize this is more a training exercise than an actual attack to face. There
is little likelihood you would face someone with the Northern Eagle Claw
skills. But developing training against what others styles would use develops
depth in understanding what is possible in an actual confrontation.
Of course the most important thing is do it first.